"The Best Feedback"

Csc_5379v1

Rahul Soman posted

Hi All,

There has been a lot of discussion about rating songs by the system, then again creating groups and rating songs, then again appreciating songs of genre and rating them. Well I see Muziboo as good feedback arena. Hence, I would like to uphold that aspect here. I am going to post below the two best comments I have recieved till date. Similarly all of you who are interested in encouraging a true style of commenting, please do.

The best comments recieved till date for my song Thenpaandi cheemayile are as below :

Jittukhannah -kuthu club member ( porullaallar – posting vaangitoam laa :p) said :
Nice try Rahul ji

yes. its just a try i think…i am wondering that you had uploaded this song 2 months before, and till you didnt made any correction into this… Gosh… How can you Dear???

Your Voice is So Good But it Dosent help with this song and also the other one…
Just Refer thenpaandi cheemaiyilae @ http://tamilcinema.dk/songs/download.asp?filmid=488&songid=3383 and http://www.esnips.com/doc/ff03d41b-4809-4912-862b-c7efe70cf23a/Kanne-Kalaimane—-Yesudas and Feel it , then Re-Consider your upload…

Your Voice is awesome without Flaws… But you gave up the Feel in this Song Buddy (and also the other one too)… i am Wondering How many peoples Commented , wowww … sema feel, Great feel and emotions, aiodaa… its Reminds me those old Mega Comedy “indha ponnu aadarathai yum, indha paiyan vaasikirathaiyum paarkum bothu Thillana Moganaamball padathulae vara Sivaji & Padmini yai nerulae paartha maadhiri irukku”From the Movie*"Karagaatakaaran"*

Never Fall in those typical comments buddy… i think most of the Muzibians didnt heard ur song fully nor they even heard the orijinal song. so they can barely say this is a Cover…

Climax comedy is “Well-rendered with lots of feel & expressions doing justice to the original !
You’re sure to go places !” ROFL

Paarthu thalaivaa… nalla kural irukku ungalluku… feel the song first… feel the emotions first… then practice pannunga nalla… off note , full note ellam indha maadhiri song ku avasiyamae illae… just emotions thaan…

Naan ellam summa passion in singing. Music lae karai katti London poi Royal phil harmonica band ai vechu symphony podanum nu kurrikoall ellam illae… ellarum paadum bothu naamallum paadina enna nu thaan pora pokkulae adichi vittu poradhu… but nalla kural vallam irukkara ungalla maathiri buddies seriya deliver pannalenna konjam manasu kekka maatudhu…

Oothara sangai oothitean…

“The great pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do!!!” arumai yana varigall… andha varigallukaavadhu konjam response pannunga thozharae… illenna “The great pleasure in life is doing what people Do you cannot!!!” nu aayirum verum pugazhchi lae mayangitaa…

nalla melodies therndhedunga… especially unnikrishnan, Rajkumar bharathi, Dheepan chakravarthi, jeyachandran nu neraya singers oda song irukku, try it… unga voice ku suit aagum… and one other thing… first lyrics ai padichi paarunga… ucharippu nalla irukanum… adhum konjam drawback unga songs lae… Keep on mind and Hope will do better next time Buddy…

(backnote)
i didnt always comment like this… but i comment frank… i cant lie with Fellow muzibians… if its hurted you some just bare it… its all for your future singing buddy…

Take care… ((((((HUGS))))))

Sukumar rajendran (rskathir) – kuthu club member said
unga songa vida unga profile photo nallarukku thalaiva…(just kidding…)

song sooper (apdinu solla mudila…)
(again kidding lol…)

franka sollanumna…sema romantica paadi irukinga…well try…

vazhga valamudan
www.youtube.com/rasukumar

I thank both my above friends for their unique style of commenting and would really appreciate it if whole of Muziboo would take a minute and applaud them both for their honest style.

Posted on January 02, 2010

Replies  

Showing 1 - 7 of 22
Ogaaaa0tib1adp_evtizpwvicxqfmrwmqgxzlagdy7h7pj4ipqcxmjnlngbmdjpfq0lm3g-vpbjeg4issdvrqqjc83eam1t1uf3tarcn-nvwysbxgggbgiseq9qu

Harshan Nambiar Pro user said

Here are some lame comments ….I have seen ….

1 – “voice suits the song…”

2- “Very nice”

Check out

Bhool gaya sab kuch

Aye dil hai Mushkil

Pukarta chala hoon mai

dil ke jharonke mein

Pmd

Prateek Dayal Muziboo staff said

Hi Harshan,

Most of my comments are ‘very nice’ or ‘great’ or ‘well done’ ….

Is there any harm done in posting comments like these if I enjoy the rendition and just want to let the uploader know?

Find & Invite Myspace, Gmail & Yahoo! contacts

Ogaaaa0tib1adp_evtizpwvicxqfmrwmqgxzlagdy7h7pj4ipqcxmjnlngbmdjpfq0lm3g-vpbjeg4issdvrqqjc83eam1t1uf3tarcn-nvwysbxgggbgiseq9qu

Harshan Nambiar Pro user said

Hi Prateek, you seldom post your comments….so bro I am not referring to your comments:-) I am referring to comments of this nature originating from active members. In my opinion the comment could also give pointers for improvement, and also pinpoint why someone liked the upload. Especially comments like voice suited the song …doesnt do much. Either the listener liked the rendition or didnt ….but they are not comfortable putting down the truth ….hence voice suited the song.
Check out

Bhool gaya sab kuch

Aye dil hai Mushkil

Pukarta chala hoon mai

dil ke jharonke mein

Tara_inia_small

Tara Balakrishnan said

I dont see any harm in saying liked or nice… There cant be rules for posting ur thoughts… btw thought the discussion is abt best comments / fbs:)

My latest post…

http://www.muziboo.com/gkuruvilla/music/tera-hone-laga-hoon-with-tara-ajab-prem-ki-ghazab-kahani

Ogaaaa0tib1adp_evtizpwvicxqfmrwmqgxzlagdy7h7pj4ipqcxmjnlngbmdjpfq0lm3g-vpbjeg4issdvrqqjc83eam1t1uf3tarcn-nvwysbxgggbgiseq9qu

Harshan Nambiar Pro user said

We are all putting down our thoughts here ….its not rules for commenting …but a general take on comments in general.
Check out

Bhool gaya sab kuch

Aye dil hai Mushkil

Pukarta chala hoon mai

dil ke jharonke mein

Tara_inia_small

Tara Balakrishnan said

Rahul… I appreciate each and every comment good/bad/lengthy/short posted in my space. the best ones r when they say they liked my rendition better than the original:)

My latest post…

http://www.muziboo.com/gkuruvilla/music/tera-hone-laga-hoon-with-tara-ajab-prem-ki-ghazab-kahani

Gk_sep2

George Kuruvilla Pro user said

Rahul,
Really hard for me to post my best comments here as such as there are so many great ones. I will say that in general, the ones I appreciate the most is when someone tells me a cover of mine moved them spiritually or emotionally (made them happy or something of that sort). When I sing, my sole purpose is to bring about some sort of an experience (be in spiritual, emotional or something else) and when I get that sort of feedback, it makes my day!
-George
Do listen to my uploads

Please login to reply to "The Best Feedback"